Skip to main content

Case study · Mystery & thriller · 2024

The Verdict Room

by Deborah Ngozi Okafor, Practicing trial attorney; first-time novelist

ASIN B0DPRT2WLX

An attorney with 30,000 words and no third act came to us for a developmental edit. Sam read the partial, restructured the second-half outline, and Deborah finished the manuscript in 14 weeks. She signed with an agent at Janklow & Nesbit three months after self-publishing.

  • Agent signed Janklow & Nesbit, 3 months post-launch
  • Macmillan NA rights, hardcover 2026
  • 73k words delivered manuscript
  • 5 months to recoup editing investment
Developmental editingLine editingBook cover design

Inside the project

The book on the desk, in five frames.

Working shots from this engagement — interview sessions, manuscript pages, cover concepts, launch day.

The structural issue

Sam reads the first 30,000 words twice. The first read is for story. The second read is for structure. On read two, the issue is clear: the first 30,000 set up a legal thriller about prosecutorial misconduct. Both of Deborah’s draft endings are courtroom verdicts. But the book she has actually written wants its climax outside the courtroom, in the prosecutor’s private office, in a conversation. Neither verdict ending serves the book.

The developmental letter says this in two paragraphs and then proposes the office scene. Deborah’s first response: a 12-line email saying she disagreed. Her second response, ten days later: a long voice memo agreeing.

She wrote the back half in 14 weeks. Sam line-edited at the end. Marcus’s cover was understated — type-driven, no photograph, the kind of cover Macmillan saw and thought worked for hardcover too.

“Sam's developmental letter told me my two endings were both wrong and then told me the right one. It made me angry for a week. Then I wrote it.”

Deborah Ngozi Okafor, Practicing trial attorney; first-time novelist

Cover rounds

Three cover concepts for The Verdict Room.

The shortlist we presented to the author before round-one revisions. The selected concept is the second in the strip.

  • Concept A — typographic, restrained palette
  • Concept B — selected and revised
  • Concept C — photographic, alternative
  • Round one — typography tightened
  • Round two — final, print-ready
Deborah Ngozi Okafor on writing The Verdict Room 02:14 A two-minute clip from the launch-day interview. The author on what changed during the project.

Project facts

The numbers behind this one.

Services used
Developmental editing, Line editing, Book cover design
Timeline
Developmental letter 3 weeks; author writing time 14 weeks; line edit 4 weeks
Investment band
$6,400–$7,800 total
Published
2024
Genre
Mystery & thriller
ASIN
B0DPRT2WLX

More case studies

Books we shipped, with names attached.

Memoir Memoir ghostwritingDevelopmental editing

Letters from the Last Year

by Sharon Linen Fordham, Retired ICU nurse; first-time author ASIN B0CM7K9PXJ

A retired ICU nurse came to us with a shoebox of handwritten letters to her late husband and seven false starts on the laptop. We turned 287 pages of letters into an 84,000-word memoir. The book hit #3 on the Amazon Memoir > Personal subcategory in launch month.

Amazon Memoir > Personal, launch month
#3
verified reviews in 90 days
247
Business book Business book ghostwritingDevelopmental editing

Operating Under Constraint

by Miguel Torres Velasco, Co-founder & CEO, supply-chain SaaS (Series C, $84M raised) ASIN B0DH1XQ4MW

A Series-B founder ghostwrote a 68,000-word operating book that became part of his Series-C narrative. The framework introduced in the book was cited by name in the lead investor's IC memo.

Series C raised, book cited in lead's IC memo
$84M
copies sold in 6 months, no traditional press
11,000
Children's Children's book writingPicture book illustration

The Soft Hour

by Aliyah & Joseph Bremer, Parents; first-time picture-book authors ASIN B0CTYHRP7Q

A 487-word picture book about a family bedtime ritual became a 2024 SCBWI Crystal Kite finalist for the Pacific West region. Watercolor illustrations by a roster illustrator paired to the manuscript.

Crystal Kite finalist, 2024
SCBWI
down from 1,800
487 words

Ready when you are

Want a case study like this one?

A 30-minute discovery call with a senior editor — no sales script, no pressure. We'll tell you whether we're the right fit for your project, what it would cost, and how long it would take.